Skip to content
Assessment Guide
Back to Articles
Analysis5 min read

Assessments in volume hiring when supervisory authorities audit automated screening in 2027

The EDPB has chosen automated decision-making in recruitment as the topic of its 2027 coordinated enforcement action. Authorities will examine the right not to be subject to solely automated decisions and the right of access in automated candidate screening. The article looks at where decisions are made in a volume funnel, what human review has to be able to do, and what employers can prepare.

By RedaktionenSource: European Data Protection Board (EDPB), news item of 11 November 2026 on the selection of the topic for the sixth coordinated enforcement action (automated decision-making in recruitment); EDPB, report on the 2025 coordinated enforcement action on the right to erasure, adopted 10 February 2026; EDPB, news item of 14 October 2025 on the 2026 topic; GDPR Articles 12, 13, 14, 15 and 22

What happened

On 11 November 2026, following its plenary meeting, the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) announced the topic of its sixth coordinated enforcement action, which is automated decision-making, including AI-driven decision-making, in recruitment. The action will look at how the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing is enforced in practice, together with the related right of access, in the context of automated candidate screening tools, including AI-driven ones. National data protection authorities will sign up on a voluntary basis in the coming weeks, and the action will be launched during 2027.

It is a short announcement, but anyone running volume hiring should read it twice. That is where screening is automated, and where test results most often serve as the filter.

What a coordinated enforcement action is

The EDPB set up its Coordinated Enforcement Framework in October 2020. A topic is chosen, the participating authorities work on it at national level, and the results are aggregated and analysed at European level, which can lead to follow-up nationally or across the EU. Earlier topics have included public sector use of cloud services, the role of the data protection officer, the right of access and the right to erasure. The 2026 topic is transparency and information obligations under Articles 12, 13 and 14 of the GDPR.

The report on the 2025 action on the right to erasure, adopted on 10 February 2026, gives a sense of what such an action involves. 32 supervisory authorities across the EEA took part. They contacted 7,943 controllers with a common questionnaire, and 764 replied. 23 authorities started with a fact-finding exercise, and 9 opened or continued formal investigations of a small number of organisations. Among the recurring problems the report lists are missing documented procedures, inadequate staff training and too little information for data subjects.

Translated to 2027, an employer that screens candidates automatically may receive a questionnaire from its national authority, and a few will be examined more closely.

Where the decision is made in a volume funnel

In a volume campaign with many applicants per vacancy, there are usually several points where a system makes a decision without a human looking at the individual candidate. Knockout questions in the application form. A cut-off score on a cognitive ability test or a personality questionnaire that rejects everyone below a threshold. A ranking in which only the top group is passed on to a recruiter. And, increasingly, an AI model that matches the application against the vacancy.

Note that the EDPB's announcement does not talk about AI alone. It talks about automated decision-making, including AI-driven decision-making. A conventional test score with an automatic threshold is just as automated as a language model. What matters is not how advanced the technology is, but whether the decision is based solely on automated processing and whether it has legal or similarly significant effects for the candidate. Being rejected for a job is hard to call anything else.

Human review and the right of access

Article 22 of the GDPR gives the data subject the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing. The exceptions include explicit consent and decisions necessary for entering into a contract. Even where an exception applies, suitable safeguards are required, including the right to obtain human intervention, to express one's point of view and to contest the decision.

This is where volume hiring is exposed. Most processes have a human somewhere in the chain, but a supervisory authority will ask whether that person actually sees and can overturn the individual decision, or merely signs off on a list the system has already sorted. If a recruiter never sees the candidates who fell below the cut-off, it is difficult to argue that the decision was not automated.

The right of access comes with it. Under Article 15, a candidate can ask whether automated decisions are being made and request meaningful information about the logic involved. "The system decided you were not a match" is not a logic. An answer that explains which test was used, which threshold was applied and why the threshold sits where it does comes closer.

What an employer can do before 2027

Map every step in the process where a candidate is screened out without a human having looked at them. For each step, decide whether it is a decision based solely on automated processing, and which legal basis and safeguards apply. Describe what the human review actually consists of, who carries it out and whether that person can change the outcome. Draft the reply to an access request before one arrives, and test whether it makes sense to a candidate. And ask the test or ATS vendor for the documentation needed to explain the logic.

None of this requires dropping automated screening. It requires being able to show how it works and where the human sits. That is what Europe's supervisory authorities will be asking in 2027.

Kilde: https://www.edpb.europa.eu/news/edpb-adopts-statement-on-review-of-the-republic-of-korea-adequacy-processor-bcr_en